85 Million Americans No Longer Qualify to Consume?
A breakdown of how real-time risk models, BNPL filters, and structural fragility are locking subprime borrowers out of the U.S. economy.”
Note: This newsletter contains information for educational purposes only, and the content below should not be considered financial advice to readers. We published a brand new short recommendation for our clients. If you would like to become our client, email laks@unicusresearch.com.
Subprime America: A Third on the Fringes of the Credit System
Prices are still high. Layoffs are piling up. And now, one-third of American adults is being quietly cut off—not by recession, but by design.
According to the most recent data, approximately one in three U.S. adults, an estimated 85 million people, fall into the “subprime” credit category, defined as having a FICO score below 670. This group spans the Fair (580–669) and Poor (300–579) credit tiers, which together account for approximately 33% of the adult population. 1
In raw score terms:
~16% are in Poor credit territory
~17% sit in the Fair range
The remainder falls across Good (21%), Very Good (25%), and Exceptional (21%) brackets
While subprime status doesn’t always correlate directly with income, it heavily overlaps with households living paycheck to paycheck, lacking financial cushions, and operating under chronic strain. These individuals face higher borrowing costs, predatory terms, or outright denial—a systemic barrier that shapes access to essentials like transportation, housing, education, and credit-driven consumption.
Notably, this 85-million-strong bloc is overrepresented in high-risk credit markets, including subprime auto loans, payday lending, rent-to-own financing, unsecured personal loans, and, increasingly, Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) services. These are the sectors most vulnerable to rising interest rates and real-time algorithmic tightening, and the first places where subprime consumers are being pushed out.
In short, subprime America isn’t just a score bracket, it’s a structural divide, increasingly governed not by FICO alone, but by dynamic, behavioral scoring systems that filter in real time. As the financial system pivots toward automated risk profiling, this group sits at the bleeding edge of what it means to become credit-invisible in a data-driven economy.
Credit Marginalization
The credit system is on track to marginalize 30% of the U.S. population simply by depriving them of access. No warning. No appeals. Just a quiet, algorithmic off-ramp from financial participation. As BNPL platforms, neobanks, and lenders adopt live underwriting models, tens of millions are losing the right to borrow, spend, and participate economically, and with that, their place within the consumer economy.
This isn’t just a credit tightening. It’s a systemic reclassification of who gets to participate in American economic life—and who doesn’t. The consequences won’t stay contained to subprime neighborhoods or second-tier lenders. This is the fracture line. And it’s widening.
BNPL platforms, hailed initially as democratizing credit access, are now playing a key role in the quiet elimination of subprime consumers from the consumption economy. This shift is being driven by real-time behavioral underwriting, automated decisioning, and tighter risk models. Here's how: